NEW YORK CITY — The NYPD doesn’t police itself when it comes to the rampant placard abuse by cops who illegally park on streets and sidewalks near stationhouses across the city, a new watchdog study found.
Only 76 illegal parking tickets went to cops out of an already-scant 876 issued in so-called “self-enforcement zones” during a five-month span in 2022, according to a city Department of Investigation study.
Those NYPD summonses to accounted for just 0.3 percent of all illegal parking tickets issued in self-enforcement zones, the study found.
Find out what's happening in New York Citywith free, real-time updates from Patch.
The study released Wednesday recommended that not only the NYPD eliminate those self-enforcement zones, but also offered a host of sweeping changes to city parking permits.
“The issuance and revocation of City-issued parking placards, and consistent, equitable enforcement of parking laws, is a quality-of-life issue for all New Yorkers,” said Jocelyn Strauber, commissioner for the Department of Investigation, in a statement.
Find out what's happening in New York Citywith free, real-time updates from Patch.
“Parking permit abuse obstructs streets and sidewalks, creating potentially dangerous conditions for pedestrians and motorists alike. And a lack of enforcement of parking laws with respect to permit-holders sends a message of special treatment that weakens public confidence in City government.”
An NYPD spokesperson said the department appreciates the study’s work.
“We are reviewing the report and will carefully consider the recommendations,” the spokesperson said in a statement.
Placard abuse has been a long-standing frustration for New Yorkers, or at least those concerned by public servants who seemingly view themselves above the law.
A popular social media account — placardabuse — daily documents what its owner calls “corruption” by city workers parked in bus lanes, metered parking for commercial vehicles and more.
Former Mayor Bill de Blasio had promised a “three-strikes” crackdown on placard abusers. But, like many of his promises, it went unfulfilled: only two placards were pulled during the 19-month enforcement effort.
Errol Louis, a prominent NY1 anchor, has deemed placard abuse as nothing less than a citywide scandal by the NYPD.
“If cops were openly stealing bagels from the nearest bodega every day on every shift, people would be outraged and (1 Police Plaza) would make heads roll,” he recently tweeted. “This isn’t much different, in my opinion.”
Much of the Department of Investigation study consisted of double-checking the NYPD’s reported illegal parking numbers.
Investigators consistently found more permit violations than those reported by NYPD officers at the same locations, according to the study. Cops are potentially only identifying roughly 8 percent of all illegally parked vehicles, based on the investigators’ numbers, the study found.
Likewise, DOI investigators found NYPD officers who responded to 311 calls about parking permit misuse typically closed those cases within 20 minutes, a timeframe “so tight as to raise questions about whether NYPD took sufficient steps to address the complaint,” the study states.
More than 90 percent of 311 complaints about parking permit misuse didn’t end with a summons, a higher rate than calls about illegal parking in general, according to the study.
And NYPD officers failed “integrity tests” in which investigators reported parking permit misuse to 311 and watched to see what cops did, the study found.
Turns out, police on all six tests didn’t take any action, and didn’t even respond at all to three complaints, according to the study.
Click Here: Real Madrid Jersey Sale
The study not only recommended that NYPD self-enforcement zones be scrapped, including the DOI’s own self-enforcement zone, but also that the city’s three agencies that issue permits — the NYPD, the Department of Transportation and Department of Education — also develop one unified permit until a fully paperless placard system is put in place.
They should conduct an audit of all placards to find whether any should be revoked under the city’s “three strikes” law, the study recommended.
“The results of that audit should be publicly reported,” the study states. “Such audit and public reporting should be conducted
annually.”
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.